Skip to main content
Toffee Ice Cream Pie

Desserts in Fort Collins

Fruit pies, cream pies, chocolate cake, and sundaes are among the desserts at Charco Broiler in Fort Collins, CO, available for pickup.

Order online

Popular Desserts to Try

Peanut Butter Cream Pie

$6.50

Cream pie with peanut butter flavor and optional toppings.

At the Heart of Charco Broiler

Charco Broiler serves desserts in pie, cake, and sundae styles, with fruit-based pies alongside cream pies. You can also have ice cream on its own, or choose chocolate cake instead of a pie.

Pair Fruit Pie with ice cream, Peanut Butter Cream Pie with chocolate syrup, or Coconut Cream Pie with strawberries. Each of these pies also has whipped cream available as an added topping.

Visit Charco Broiler in Fort Collins, CO for pickup or dine-in. Your Ice Cream Sundae is available with one or two scoops; add caramel syrup and baked apples, or finish it with whipped cream.

Desserts to Try

“Old school steakhousebwith amazing foorld. The steak is done to perfection every time. The Pies are the best!”

Coconut Cream Pie

$6.50

Coconut cream pie with optional dessert toppings.

“We enjoyed a luncheon dining experience. Server was attentive, professional and helpful. Menu was varied and portions were plentiful. We ordered filet mignon, chicken fried steak, ribeye steak & hamburger. Dessert was tasty, unique (peanut butter pie & coconut pie) and portions were great. Overall, it was a terrific experience and our party enjoyed dining at a local business with overall high food, service & facility.”

Ice Cream

$2.50+

Ice cream comes in a required choice of one or two scoops.

“Rosie was one of the best hospitality professionals that I have had the pleasure of being seated with in a long time. She was very experienced and excited to give us the history of the restaurant. Drinks were immaculate, our meal was scrumptious, dessert were mouth watering. We definitely left in a food comma.”

Frequently Asked Questions

What are your most popular desserts options?

Our guests love these customer favorites. If you're visiting us these are some of the food options we recommend most often.

  • Peanut Butter Cream Pie — Peanut butter cream pie can be customized with optional ice cream, chocolate or caramel syrup, strawberries, or whipped cream.
  • Banana Cream Pie — Banana custard fills a pastry crust; optional additions include ice cream, baked apples, syrups, strawberries, or whipped cream.
  • Chocolate Dream Cake — This chocolate dessert can be customized with add-ons such as baked apples, strawberries, caramel or chocolate syrup, whipped cream, and ice cream.
  • Toffee Ice Cream Pie — A pie combining ice cream and toffee flavor; optional toppings include caramel or chocolate syrup, strawberries, or whipped cream.
  • Coconut Cream Pie — A creamy coconut-filled pie in a pastry crust; optional additions include whipped cream, strawberries, ice cream, or syrup.